Hesperia Animal Shelter: $40,000 Evaluation Sparks Debate Over Transparency
HESPERIA, Calif. (VVNG.com) — The Hesperia City Council on Tuesday, February 18, 2025, discussed a proposed $40,000 contract for a third on-site evaluation of the Hesperia Animal Shelter, which sparked concerns over transparency and the effectiveness of previous evaluations.
After a lengthy discussion and public comment, the Council ultimately voted to table the item for further review.
The agenda item requested that the Council authorize the City Manager to enter into a Professional Services Agreement (PSA) with Animal Shelter Services, LLC for an evaluation of the shelter’s operations.
City staff emphasized that the goal of periodic evaluations was to ensure the shelter provides the best possible care for animals in the community.
However, transparency surrounding past evaluations has become a contentious issue, with both Council members and residents raising concerns about the lack of accessible information and the effectiveness of prior reports.
A City Staff member presented the proposal, noting that this would be the third evaluation of the shelter since 2016.
She highlighted the improvements that had followed earlier evaluations, including nearly $900,000 in facility upgrades, such as the addition of a pet visitation room, outdoor security, and a small playground.
Additionally, staff said they have worked on recommendations to increase staffing, improve training, and strengthen the volunteer program.
However, she stressed that this third evaluation would help track progress and identify new opportunities for improvement.
“There are exciting new features to the contract, such as providing shelter advocates an opportunity to meet with the vendor and discuss shelter operations,” staff explained. “This evaluation will allow us to compare and contrast where we were, where we are now, and answer any questions the Council may have.”
Despite these assurances, public comments were overwhelmingly critical of the proposal. Several speakers expressed frustration with the repeated evaluations and the perceived lack of tangible action.
A voicemail submitted by a resident named Kimberly criticized the proposed evaluation as redundant. “I ask you, what is the purpose of this evaluation that you want to have done?” Kimberly said. “Will it tell us anything new, or will it be another expensive document that confirms what has already been stated? The animals in the shelter don’t need another evaluation, they need action.”
Kim Jones also raised concerns over the cost, describing $40,000 as a significant sum, particularly given the state of the shelter. “You could save a lot of lives with that money,” Jones said. “Why not use it for something that helps the animals directly, like bringing in a veterinarian or improving the shelter’s infrastructure?”
Gina Whalen voiced her frustration as well, questioning why a third evaluation was needed. “Why are you gonna waste taxpayers’ money?” she asked. “If the city can’t get it together to repair and maintain the shelter based on prior recommendations, then why keep going down this same road?”
Robert Davey, another concerned resident, called for a new auditing company, expressing dissatisfaction with the previous evaluations and the handling of the reports. “This $40,000 should go towards a new shelter,” Davey said. “It’s a waste of our money, and we’re not going anywhere. We’re tired of just talking to the wall.”
Davey emphasized that taxpayers deserve more than just another report, especially when the city has yet to release the 2016 and 2023 audit reports.
“If you’re going to use our tax dollars and let him claim attorney-client privilege, and not release the information to us… are you kidding me?” Davey said.
During the Council’s deliberations, Mayor Pro Tem Cameron Gregg raised concerns about transparency, particularly regarding past reports. “I think the evaluation is necessary, but I do take exception to this auditing company who has blatantly denied us access to these reports,” Gregg said. “I’d like to see what that framework is, what we’re paying for, and what exactly we’re looking for in this audit.”
City staff acknowledged the concerns, noting that previous evaluations had included personnel-related information, which was difficult to share due to privacy concerns.
However, they suggested that this issue could be addressed in future reports. “We can easily manage that this time around by excluding staff information,” staff said.
Council members also discussed the possibility of issuing a request for proposals (RFP) to explore other options for the evaluation.
Hesperia City Manager Rachel Molina confirmed that the city could move forward with other bidders if desired.
“I can work with the attorney to see if we can present that information to the city council,” Molina said. “While the city sees a benefit from using the same consultant, it is not our only option. We can come back with a scope of work for the council’s review.”
The staff emphasized that the audits play a crucial role in securing necessary funds and fostering ongoing improvements in city services. She explained, ‘I’m sorry that the public doesn’t always feel that way, but the evaluations really do serve as a tool for staff to continue requesting budgeting for certain things and to continue improving services.’
Following further discussion, Council Member Chris Ochoa made a motion to table the item and direct staff to explore alternative evaluators, as well as to provide more clarity on the scope of services.
The motion was seconded by Gregg, and the Council voted unanimously, 5-0, to delay the decision.
This motion allows the Council time to review potential alternatives before moving forward with the evaluation process.
The delay also provides the public with an opportunity to engage further in the discussion and ensure that taxpayer dollars are being spent effectively on improvements for the shelter.
As the debate continues, residents remain vocal in their call for tangible action to improve the Hesperia Animal Shelter, with many urging the Council to prioritize the welfare of the animals over additional reports and evaluations.
The issue is expected to return to the City Council for further discussion in the coming weeks.
For those interested in watching the full recording of the February 18th City Council meeting, the video is available for viewing here: Watch the Meeting.
Copyright 2026 Victor Valley News Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.




